NASDAL: Covid-19 resilience of mixed NHS/private practices - the findings
NASDAL members act for over 25 per cent of UK dentists (approximately 3,000 dentists) and in its brief to the SLWG, NASDAL provided an independent and informed assessment of the current fiscal position of the dental sector and observed that:
- The key factor in the risk profile for a dental practice is the level of pre-Covid-19 debt:
- Risk is higher for a significant minority of practice owners, particularly those who have recently bought
practices, that are highly geared.
- The availability of CBILS and Bounce Back Loans has resulted in additional borrowing which practices will
not need to be repaid until mid-2021.
- With the proviso that payment of NHS contract values are maintained and the lifting of the activity-based assessment metric is not re-implemented, NASDAL’s baseline assessment is that there is unlikely to be significant insolvency of dental practices over the next 12 to 18 months.
- NASDAL anticipate any cash flow impacts and potential practice insolvencies to emerge in late 2021.
NASDAL developed a financial model, with a number of assumptions. A mixed practice within the model is one with approximately 50 per cent of their income coming from an NHS arrangement. With assumptions regarding pre-Covid-19 net profits, fee reductions, lab and material costs, PPE costs and associate and employee cost savings, both private (NHS income<20 per cent) and mixed practices appeared to be in fund deficit following loan repayments.
Indeed, based on these assumptions, a typical mixed practice would suffer net losses of £9,246 whilst a private practice, losses of £71,269.
Alan Suggett, media officer of NASDAL and head of the dental business unit at UNW commented, “We are not for one moment suggesting that the UK is now full of poor dentists or that the UK government should support zombie businesses. However, it is clear that most dental practices are fundamentally sound businesses and to see a good number in potential difficulty purely because of capital loan repayments, is a real concern. That is why it was key for us that in the recommendations, a government guaranteed loan support scheme to underpin lenders confidence in supporting dental practices and dental laboratories at risk was included.
“Practices with potential cashflow deficits due to loan capital repayments will still be trading profitably. To see them go out of business and all that entails for the owners, team and patients would be a terrible waste.”
The nine recommendations that the SLWG made to the CDO and government were:
- An extension of the Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme for the dental sector.
- An extension of the maximum repayment term (currently six years) for both the Coronavirus Business Interruption Loan Scheme (CBILS), and the Bounce Back Loan Scheme (BBLS) applicable across the breadth of the dental sector.
- Eligibility for business rate relief for all dental practices.
- Eligibility for Retail, Hospitality and Leisure Grant (RHLGF) for the dental sector.
- A support package for dental laboratories that service NHS dental practices.
- A government-guaranteed loan support scheme to underpin lenders confidence in supporting dental practices and dental laboratories at risk.
- A government commitment to target additional funding toward an expanded NHS dental provision to address inequalities by:
a. Commissioning additional dental capacity for routine dental care and increase patient access.
b. Commissioning additional capability and capacity for non-mandatory services; to include domiciliary services for care homes and community settings, sedation services, advanced restorative work to address evidenced needs (e.g. endodontics).
c. Flexible commissioning to support prevention initiatives.
- Funding for urgent research into the fallow time post dental aerosol-generating procedures.
- For the General Dental Council (GDC) to return the 20/21 Annual Retention Fee (ARF) to Dental Technicians.
Alan Suggett continued, “We await hearing a considered response to our recommendations.”